How to tell when apples are ripe and ready to pick?

Need help figuring out if your apples are ripe for picking? Read on for practical tips so there’s no guessing required.

apples in bowl on grass
Prairie Sensation apples, an early summer dwarf tree variety from my front yard in Manitoba.

Watch the Video: How to Tell When Apples are Ripe

Five Tips for How to Tell Apples Are Ripe

Here are five tips from the Apple Cookbook on how to tell if your apples are ripe for picking.

1. Variety

Knowing the variety of apple you have can help you narrow down when you should start to consider whether or not your apples need picking. Apples and crab apples can typically be classified as early summer (July to mid August), mid-summer (mid-August to early September) or fall apples (mid-September to October).

If you don’t know the variety, no problem, there are plenty of other ways to judge ripeness. Just don’t be fooled into picking your apples just because your neighbours are picking theirs! You may have a different variety and just because they’re picking, doesn’t mean you should!

Start keeping tabs on your apple tree and soon you’ll get a sense of when your apples are typically ready to harvest. Although, some years there can be up to 3 to 4 week differences in harvest times.

red fall apples
These fall apples are picked late September, early October in Manitoba – after first frost.

Did you know that some apples are best when picked after a frost? You bet! These red fall apples (variety may be a Haralson or Frostbite from the Univeristy of Minnesota) are super sweet and store really well, but aren’t harvested until mid-October.

These Goodland apples are often ready towards late August.  They should be yellow with a blush of red.

goodland apples
Goodland Apples – Manitoba

These rescue crab apples are one of the first to ripen in early August. The ones here are over ripe and have become grainy, but still good for juicing.

over ripe crab apples
Rescue crab apples – early summer Manitoba

2. Colour

Look carefully at the color of your apples, especially the base or ground color – it may be green, creamy or yellow.  Watch it change as the apples mature and wait for the entire apple to change.  Unless you have a green apple variety like Granny Smith, most apples will turn a softer shade of green or even a creamy yellow when they’re fully ripe.

Here’s what our Prairie Sensation apples look like in early July. They’re a good size and have the start of a red blush, but the base color is much too green.

under ripe apples
Prairie Sensation – not ripe

Here’s that same apple three weeks later, in August. Quite a difference, but if you’re not patient enough, you’d miss out on this transformation and would assume you have a tart green apple instead of the sweet delicious red apple you could enjoy if you wait.

ripe apple
Prairie Sensation – ripe

3. Ease of Separation from Tree

twist apple for ripeness
Prairie Sensation – Manitoba

Ripe apples come off a tree quite easily – they don’t need to be tugged or pulled. Simply hold the bottom of the apple, lift it against the stem and twist. If it doesn’t come off easily, it’s not ripe.

4. Flavor

Use an old fashioned taste test to judge the ripeness of your apples. Unless you have a crab apple or a tart apple variety, your apples should not be sour and make you pucker. It’s amazing how much sweeter your apples will become with a couple of days of sunshine.

Here on the prairies people often pick under ripe apples because they think all prairie apples are sour – which is totally untrue. We have some amazingly sweet apples – you just need to let them ripen!

But don’t wait too long!  If you’re apples seem mealy, they’re over ripe.

 5. Pip Color

pip color
The pips in this Prairie Sensation apple are just starting to turn brown. This apple could have used a few more days on the tree to fully ripen.

Pick an apple and slice it open to see what color the pips or seeds are.  A ripe apple, no matter what size or variety, will have dark brown pips.  Here’s the pips in one of our apples that fell off the tree mid-July. Notice that one seed is just starting to turn brown while the two beside it are still white.  Even though the apple fell off the tree, it is no where near being ripe enough to pick.

Keep testing and tasting your apples, it’s amazing how quickly they can ripen when conditions are hot and sunny. Take photos or just keep tabs on what your ideal apple looks and tastes like and after a couple of successful harvests you’ll know exactly what to look for.

Dropped Apples Don’t Mean They’re Ripe

dropped apples with bowl
Dropped apples are not necessarily sign of ripe apples. Check for signs of ripeness before harvesting. But do collect dropped apples to prevent the spread of pests and disease.

I know it’s alarming when apples start dropping, but having some apples fall before they are ripe is normal. But it doesn’t necessarily mean the tree is ready for picking.

Do not judge ripeness by dropped apples alone. If a tree is suffering from environmental stress (too hot, cold, wet or dry), is overloaded or suffers from insect or wind damage it will drop apples prematurely. Use the tips listed above to determine ripeness.

Harvest Apples In Stages

Not all of the apples on a tree will be ready to harvest at the same time. Typically, apples along the outer edges of the tree will ripen before those towards the center of the tree. Ideally, you’d want to pick apples on more than one day, covering a span of one to two weeks. Picking in this manner will ensure you get consistently ripe apples.

But, I get it, sometimes you just want to pick them all and get on with it! If you’re juicing, saucing,baking or making jams and jellies with your apples, it’s okay to have a mix of overripe, underripe and just right apples.  For this type of picking, you want to pick when the majority of apples are perfectly ripe.

goodland apples
Goodland apples – Manitoba

Picking in Your Community

In the mood to pick some apples, but don’t have your own apple tree?  Check out fruit rescuing organizations in your community that match up people interested in picking fruit with people who have too much fruit. Google fruit rescuing in your community. If there’s no formal fruit picking group, let friends, neighbors and social media know you’re looking to help someone pick their apples. There’s bound to be someone who has more apples than they can manage.

apples in bowl on lawn
I love prairie apples like these early season prairie sensation apples.

I LOVE local apples – not just the flavor, but the whole idea of them. After all, apples prompted me to launch Fruit Share – TedX Getty Stewart, write my fruit cookbooks and start this website. So please, share your apple pictures and stories with me! I’d love to hear your experiences (good or bad), see what varieties you’re growing and how you use your bounty. Share your comments below or post a photo and tag me on Instagram @getgettys or Facebook @GettyStewart.HomeEconomist.

Sign up to get articles by Getty delivered to your inbox. You’ll get recipes, practical tips and great food information like this. Getty is a Professional Home Economist,  speaker and writer putting good food on tables and agendas.  She is the author of Manitoba’s best-selling Prairie Fruit Cookbook, Founder of Fruit Share, a mom and veggie gardener.

Similar Posts


    1. Yes! You’re absolutely right. People jump the gun because a few apples will start to drop early, but if you wait until they’re truly ripe they’re so much tastier!

    1. Would love for you to join my list. Enter your email address at the top left column. If you’re on mobile, change to the desktop view and you’ll find the subscription at the top left under the main banner for my site. Thanks.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.